By using food rations and thyroxine supplements, I manipulated the growth and differentiation of tadpoles of the toad Bufo americanus to test the hypothesis that the plasticity in metamorphic timing can be lost. A significant food effect indicated that tadpoles that grew rapidly during the middle period of the experiment metamorphosed earlier than slow-growing tadpoles. The changes in growth induced early and late in this experiment did not influence metamorphic timing. There was a significant thyroxine effect: all tadpoles treated with thyroxine metamorphosed early. All thyroxine-treated tadpoles metamorphosed at the same time, indicating that differentiation at the time of thyroxine supplementation was independent of growth rate. A food-by-thyroxine interaction provided evidence that the growth rate/differentiation antagonism may have been active at least during the middle of the experiment. This suggests that the growth rate/differentiation antagonism is decoupled or overridden during later stages of larval development. This result implies limits to metamorphic plasticity and is consistent with a fixed-rate model of amphibian metamorphosis.